My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark podcast

My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

3 star

This week’s hometowns include a creepy neighbor story and a haunted university.  See for privacy information.

My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark Podcast Comments

What do you think about My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark podcast? Ask the community a question about My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark!

Please wait! My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark podcast comments loading...

My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark Podcast Reviews

Free International Money Transfer 💸Enjoy high maximum transfers into more than 20 currencies while saving up to 90% over local banks! The cheap, fast way to send money abroad. Free transfer up to 500 USD!AdvertorialScore: 5/5

Boring nowSo boring. Maybe they ran out of jokes and murders to tell.Score: 1/5

NoAll they do is talk about themselves. Tried to get thru two episodes and couldn’t because they talked about nothing for half an hour before finally getting into the crime story. 0 stars. So irritating..Score: 1/5

It’s the bestThis is the only podcast that puts out weekly content that I subscribe to. I’ve been listening since the beginning and I have never wanted to stop ❤️.Score: 5/5

Great show but recently quality has sufferedI’ve been a listener since 2017 and have until recently would have rated this five stars consistently. But in the past year or two, the volume of ads relative to content has increased noticeably. I realize we all gotta pay the bills, and I know they need to promote their network and other shows, but it’s a question of degree, and the ratio of ad to show has become a lot closer to fifty-fifty than it used to be. That plus the apparent lack of interest in telling stories about true crime (there’s been a lot of urban legend content recently) makes me think that maybe Karen and Georgia just aren’t into this anymore. And if they aren’t, I’m not sure why I should still be..Score: 3/5

Best friendsThose complaining about the “rambling” clearly miss the point of this podcast. Their cases covered are researched well, comedy on point and best of all the intros. Sometimes I’ll just listen to the intros to make it feel like we’re all hanging out. 5* always has been always will be..Score: 5/5

My Go-To PodcastI’ve been listening to this podcast since their first year of podcasting and I’ve never stopped. Some podcasts come and go but My Favourite Murder has been a consistent one. Highly recommend!!!!.Score: 5/5

PandemicThanks for keeping me (relatively) sane this year..Score: 5/5

Foul languageI’m sure these ladies don’t care about my opinion but they’re foul language makes me not care about theirs...decent content, offensive delivery....Score: 1/5

Too many “quilt” + live show re-runsI do love this show but the amount of “quilt” (ie cba) episodes that are released every week is honestly such a disappointment! I get excited for the show’s release every Thursday and to find out after the intro banter that it’s just going to be a re-run of an episode I’ve already listened to (or worse, a live show) I feel really let down. Lazy podcasting from the hosts, have now unsubscribed :(.Score: 2/5

Quality is..questionable?The quality of the episodes aren’t what they used to be. I waited it out the last few months.. However, to no avail there’s still a lot of filler. For example with live shows, chatting (like 20-30 minutes of it), and promotional channel episodes (not what I signed up for). I even spotted two or three times of a repeat in content (use of a live-show or old stories). I’m assuming that it’s accidental. It just feels like it’s getting lazy. If they wanted to do smaller episodes (like listener stories) of just chatting, that would be cool - have a blast..Just get it in the schedule, like officially..Score: 1/5

Long time listener, first time skipperI’ve been a die hard MFM listener since episode 2 and have always love Georgia and Karen’s dynamic but lately... not so much. I used to really enjoy the 15-20 mins of chatting at the beginning of each episode and I was never a “skipper” as they call it. Now it’s become 45 minutes of self promotion which isn’t great. I get that you have a podcast network now (which is great!) but talking about what’s happening this week on every single other show is not what I’m downloading your episodes for. Exactly Right corner is not it. Add the very clear lack of interest in doing the podcast itself (repeats, quilt episodes, one story episodes etc) and its now going to be a no from me..Score: 2/5

BoringWas interested to listen to a podcast called My favorite murder but all I got was a couple dits talking about hairspray.Score: 1/5

A safe place to be yourselfThis is the only podcast that truly feels like a positive community and more than just a one-way monologue from the podcasters. I started listening for the true crime and I stayed for Karen and Georgia and all Murderinos..Score: 5/5

My favLove you guys, love this podcast. So glad I found you!.Score: 5/5

♥️Hahahaha to the whiny turds complaining about ~foul language~. Imagine policing the free content you choose to listen to because your vacuous little head is offended by adult words. Snore. Great podcast. We’re here for the random banter with K&G as much as we are for the true crime. They’ve never been short of honest, and if that includes promoting their empire and all the other podcasters they’re working with, so be it. At least they don’t torture us with 9,000 previews in our feeds like Wondery does..Score: 5/5

Picking it back upIt seems the past year has had it’s effects on everyone and humans running podcasts are no exception. I love this podcast and though the last year’s content from the ladies has honestly tanked a bit - the overall podcast is great if you listen to the older episodes. I like that they seem to have taken the constructive criticism here and are beginning to put more effort into new stories with better research. Thank you humbly for my free entertainment. I know quarantine has been hard so naturally less thrilling personal stories makes sense - people should chill. Could do without *so* much exactly right ads, though. I am literally gonna go bananas - I said no ads! Please. Thank you. Peace..Score: 4/5

Over itWas a huge fan for years - I can’t even listen anymore- they have lost their mojo. They don’t care about getting anything accurate with such sensitive topics - they don’t even pretend that they put any hard work into the podcast. They act like it’s a joke, and it shows with such crappy episodes over and over..Score: 1/5

Making my way throughI’ve started from the beginning and I’m in March 2019 right now. For now I enjoy, during this pandemic, the banter of Karen and Georgia have between delving into murder/gasp-worthy related topics as it feels like I have two friends while I’m working around my home. I like that it’s not 100% researched, I’ll do that on my own and use their podcast as a jumping point (as most people should get into a habit of doing for anything they consume). And for the people that think they shouldn’t swear too much? Don’t listen, that simple. I’m sure there are many male dominated media products with similar or more swearing without the same poor reviews and comments..Score: 5/5

Used to be ObsessedI love their friendship, I love so many of the older episodes. These days, it seems like they are not as interested in the thing that brought them together: telling stories of true crime. In each month, there’s maybe one episode with new stories (others being “quilt episodes” or repeats), and there’s a lot of time spent on the books, the other podcasts they’re producing. Because other people are now doing the research, the stories are less personal, and often (Georgia’s) stories feel off-topic and read directly from the page. I’ve started listening to this one later and later each week. I hope they can recapture the classic energy..Score: 3/5

So much love 💖This pod has become such a comfort listen. i’ve been on the MFM train for years and now georgia and karen feel like familiar friends :’) i love how their storytelling process has evolved, and in my opinion any changes in delivery over the years are natural and welcome. i rly admire these guys and the dynamic they’ve cultivated - and am so proud of them for keeping this podcast going for 5 YEARS (and during a goddamn pandemic), while taking an increasingly nuanced and intentional approach to the true crime stories they cover. K & G, thank u so much for your mental health advocacy and engaging storytelling 💛 love y’all & keep stayin sexy!!!.Score: 5/5

Serotonin in podcast formAmazing that a show about murder can give so many a reason for living, but this hilarious, often heartfelt, and always entertaining podcast has kept me going through some incredibly hard times. And I know I’m far from alone in that. It’s like hanging out with your two super cool older sisters, swapping stories and getting remarkably poignant life advice, all while learning about who chopped whose head off in 1953. I’ve recommended it to everyone in my life, so now I’m recommending it to whoever’s reading this..Score: 5/5

My favourite murderAlright if they could keep some of their uniformed opinions about politics out of it, they try to hard not to offend anyone and blame everything on Trump, geez how original they should stick more to true crime instead..Score: 1/5

Hands down, best everAbsolutely love the chatter and the giggles. Feels like I'm hanging out with my girlfriends, except I don't have to share the snacks! I’ve been listening for about 4 years now. Twice a week for four years, plus one live show in Vancouver (not the one with the lost audio, the Queen E one - front row bc in a super fan like that). Why on earth would someone dedicate that much time to listening in on two other people talk? Because it’s that good. See you on Monday and Thursday, KG&GH ❤️.Score: 5/5

Just not the sameUse to LOVE this podcast. They seem much more interested in running a network than telling a story. Even with an entire team behind them they continue to release quilt episodes and old live shows- very disappointed..Score: 3/5

Not what it used to beAs many others have said, I used to be obsessed with MFM. The vibe has totally changed and it’s getting very lame. MFM turned me on to podcasts and now that I’ve ventured out and started listening to other shows, it’s definitely turned into something I listen to when I have nothing else. The quilt episodes gotta go as do the lame stories they’ve been sharing. There are so many interesting stories out there about actual MURDER rather than what they’ve been covering lately. if they just took some time to research then they would know that. All they both talk about is how boring their lives are since covid. Why not take this down time to really pump out some amazing content? This is your job, after all. Also Georgia, can you find any other words to use than cussing? I’m no prude but it really shows your education..Score: 2/5

All time favourite podcast!!!Will listen to these ladies till the day I die. Amazing story tellers & they make me laugh out loud. Stay sexy & don’t get murdered!.Score: 5/5

Love this podcast!Karen and Georgia are such hilarious, genuine people. When I listen to My Favourite Murder I feel like I am hanging out with two friends, or my sisters. I love the friendship they have. When I listen, I feel less lonely. The stories can be fascinating, gruesome and awful, but are told with such compassion and humour that I feel like it’s going to be okay. As someone who struggles with depression and anxiety on a day to day, I really appreciate their candid discussions of their own mental health journeys, from therapy and medication to learning how to change old patterns of thinking that are no longer helpful. I’ve been listening since near the beginning and their voices have been such a comforting and hilarious presence in my life..Score: 5/5

Trans youthThanks for standing up for the youth! Republicans are vile. Waving from Canada!.Score: 5/5

RealityKaren and Georgia have from the beginning been honest that they are both just fascinated with true crime well also being professional comedians. They never claimed to be researchers and they never claimed that this podcast was going to be 100% scientific or technically accurate. If you’re looking for a deep dive of true crime facts listen to Jensen and holes. Also, to other people in the other reviews, understand that we are in a pandemic and things are extremely hard Karen and Georgia are undertaking a lot of things outside of the podcast while adjusting to life as we all have, have you not struggled this year? I have. The first 30 minutes are, yes not usually about true crime, but are honest and vulnerable and when you listen to other people talk about their struggle especially in the pandemic it can help. Karen and Georgia are perhaps some of the most authentic people. I have always loved this podcast and if it’s not for you great but let’s not hate on people who are doing their best and still putting a quality content that a lot of people rely on as a highlight of their week. Stay sexy..Score: 5/5

My Favorite Podcast!I’ve been listening to the ladies for years! It’s such easy listening and I love their hilarious banter before they begin their stories of the week, as well as their openness about issues that many of us deal with. I listen to a lot of true crime but Georgia and Karen are always top of my list! 🖤.Score: 5/5

One of my first favourite podcastsI’m not a Karen or a Georgia but some kind of twisted hybrid of the two with a dash of Mimi’s attitude and Elvis’ love of cookies, to boot..Score: 5/5

Still love but….Still and always will love the show, but I wonder if Georgia ever cries herself to sleep over how rude and snarky Karen is to her sometimes. Not cool and it’s becoming more and more noticeable. If I had a friend that talked to me like I am a complete moron, well they wouldn’t be my friend much longer.Score: 5/5

The bestMy favourite podcast ever.Score: 5/5

Great!Been listening for years. I feel like these women are my best friends. Laughing out loud is a common occurrence. Thanks for making me feel like my mental health issues are totally normal!!.Score: 5/5

💘My favourite podcast. The one that got me into podcasts in the first place some years ago, and the one that all other podcasts have to try to measure up to..Score: 5/5

💜This is the best podcast ever. I love Karen and Georgia and I think they are super funny and interesting. They are amazing at storytelling. I have introduced the podcast to many of my friends and even though they’re not a murderino like me they loved it. Thank you for all you do and making my long drives to work every pleasant. 💜 love you all. Ps. My boyfriend and I always use your quotes in our conversations :)).Score: 5/5

I don’t even really like true crimeYet I’ve been listening from the beginning. I’m just here for the friendship and the unparalleled back and forth!.Score: 5/5

Two badass podcastersGeorgia and Karen feel like friends. They are funny and sassy and I look forward to their episodes every week! Keep up the great work!.Score: 5/5

Still greatYou’re still the one, still the one I walk to, the only one I dream of, you’re still the one I listen to at night... still the one!.Score: 5/5

My favourite murder or my favourite personal opinions on the narratives being pushed?I’ve listened since the beginning it’s gone downhill to say the least, this shouldn’t even be called a crime podcast anymore because the first 45mins is these two talking about politics and the ongoings of the world (which they have no business doing, literally no one cares about a couple of middle aged narrative pushers opinions on political matters) ... that’s not what people came here to listen for. We want to hear stories, I actually started skipping the audio to where they begin the story but even that is pointless now because all they do is play reruns of live shows or old episodes. I will no longer be a listener and support these two ding dongs, there’s way better crime podcasts out there that actually stick to what the podcast is supposed to be about don’t waste your time unless you want to listen to a politicized script..Score: 1/5

Long time fanI never miss an episode. These women are my people. Resist the urge to skip when you first start listening. You will miss out entirely on part of what makes this show great.Score: 5/5

Pandemic palsThis has been my go to podcast during the pandemic, if ever you feel alone or isolated Karen and Georgia always make you feel a bit less lonely ❤️.Score: 5/5

NopeI love true crime comedy podcasts. But not this one. I do not like the banter between the hosts and I do not find them funny or entertaining..Score: 1/5

Hands down, best podcast ever!With exception of Serial, Georgia and Karen have raised the bar beyond reach of any other podcast. Their chemistry and banter cannot be beat. Combined with their brand of storytelling and the interesting stories they tell, is brilliant. I saw their show live in Toronto. Seeing how they interact in person, brought their chemistry to a new appreciation for me. Being in a 3000 seat theatre if screaming, mostly women and some men, was so infectious. Also, Steven was there! I have pics 😉 Love, love, love! Cannot recommend highly enough!.Score: 5/5

Favourite podcastI love the ramblings!!!!!! I’m a new listener and trying to hear all the episodes it’s been great I feel like I have friends over even though it’s quarantine..Score: 5/5

Happy for your success but...Ladies, I am so proud of your accomplishments. You have a successful network that you created and run but MFM is what brought you here. Please remember the earlier times when you were recording in Georgia’s non-air conditioned apartment. You seemed so enthusiastic back then. Now, you rely so much on the old live shows or re-runs. I realize you have more responsibilities but please don’t give up on the podcast and the fans that helped you get here. Thanks.Score: 3/5

👍Still one of the best, I’ve been listening for years and I still can’t wait to see what’s next. Chef’s kisses, these women are the best..Score: 5/5

Absolute deal breaker. (Ep. 269)It is *thoroughly disappointing (after years of listening) to learn that this podcast endorses medicalizing children who cannot consent to life-altering changes to their developing bodies. Children do not have the capacity or life experience to consent to drugs and alcohol. How on earth could they give an informed consent to extreme medical intervention? These are decisions only adults can make. See Kiera Bell and the Tavistock. Hers is only one very tragic story. There are 10’s of thousands! It’s been fun. But this podcast has crossed a line while supporting the abuse of children. Children cannot consent and they are not medical experiments..Score: 1/5

My loveI’ve unsubscribed to the fan cult but I still love and appreciate all that this wonderful podcast provides me for free ... thank you for everything!.Score: 5/5

Horrible1st 40 mins is them cackling over politics and some story about their dogs or drinking wine at home. Horrible. And not a true crime podcast. Reading an article isn’t true crime.Score: 1/5

Payoneer 💰Payoneer is an online payment platform that lets you transfer money from any corner of the world! A best and must have payment service for every blogger, traveler, freelancer, affiliate marketer, consultant, virtual assistant, business person, online sellers, and receivers. Earn $25 for free by joining Payoneer. Sign Up Now!AdvertorialScore: 5/5

Used to Love ItI used to love this podcast but these two have gotten so self indulgent that I unsubscribed. They complain about fans correcting them when it’s clearly part of the territory and don’t seem to appreciate their listeners anymore..Score: 2/5

Love itThat’s all Just love it.Score: 5/5

How to destroy a podcastThis was a solid weekly listen until the past 8 months. The hosts don’t do their own research anymore and as a result read off their parts like a book report; gone are the witty insights and openings for banter. It feels dead. Most insufferable is that Georgia has become so intolerable to listen to with her staccato inflections of speech and her overbearing personal affronts in every story. I don’t know how Karen hasn’t had an intervention with her. Personally I like the live show rehash because they’re a great example of the wit and charm of what this podcast once was. Please listen to your audience and read your room. We have left..Score: 1/5

Your passion is goneI have listened to so many episodes and you’re honestly one of the reasons I’m so passionate about true crime now - HOWEVER, for the last 6+ months you can sense an obvious lack of passion and chemistry. You stopped doing your own research for the most part which makes listening to you sound like I’m listening to an audiobook. Half the time I listen to 30 minutes of you talking about yourself just to encounter an old live episode (which I hope you can understand how annoying that is). I’ve switched to Rotten Mango and Cult Liter (depending on my mood) because they get straight to the point and you can tell that they care about what they’re producing. I will give this podcast a try again in a few months but it’s been such a drastic change from what it used to be - hopefully you can get back your passion and the following you used to have. If not maybe it’s time to move on..Score: 1/5

A long time listenerAI haven't been listening since the very beginning but I have listened to almost all the episodes. I have always been annoyed listening to the live shows so I always skipped. I also always skipped ahead to the actual murder stories on the episodes, but now its becoming increasingly longer than usual. The minisodes are becoming more and more just them talking and its becoming annoying. I can tell a change in the way the shows are set up and its making me not want to listen..Score: 3/5

Long time listenerI’ve been listening for 3 years know and still love the show.This pod cast got me through loosing both my parents. Like they say laughter is the best medicine. It has changed a lot but I’m still entertained for hours. It’s like listening to some old friends. Love those ladies.Score: 5/5

Stay sexy and take your job seriouslyUsed to love this show! It was my favorite podcast once. Loved their jokes, stories , banter ~ basicay everything. Lately the quality has gone downhill to say the least. Making podcasts and coming up with new stories is not easy, but a lot of other podcasters are putting in the extra effort, including podcasts on their own network! Seems like they are just not interested in making the podcast anymore and make it appear like they are doing their listeners a favor by recording ~ it’s literally your job!.Score: 3/5

My bffsLOVE THIS PODCAST. I’ve been listening since December 2019. I started at episode 1 and was caught up within a few months. Karen and Georgia feel like my best friends. I tell everyone who will listen about this podcast. Even in a global pandemic and being virtual since last March, I can still feel their charm and chemistry that has been around since the beginning. I can’t wait to see them live for the first time. Thank you, Karen and Georgia..Score: 5/5

Was... My favorite podcast by far!! But..Updating my review.. I just don’t listen anymore! They got me into true crime! I went back to the old shows and they were Just. So. Good. I love the live shows and I’m even okay with quilts. I loved the Lacey Peterson episode. I have always loved the banter but it does seem realllly therapy heavy lately. I know it’s hard to keep things fresh but hope that K&G get their inspiration back or maybe do the ‘seasons’ approach? I’d rather have less episodes but higher quality. It’s hard to say but it feels like there is a real ‘phone it in’ attitude for the past 6 months (especially from Georgia - I’m sorry girl!) but maybe that’s just this pandemic. I know you guys are boss b*s now with your own network- maybe that is something you’re more interested in pursuing?? Still love you, but I’m just not a regular listener anymore..Score: 3/5

The older sisters I wish I grew up withLike a big hug in my ears. Thanks for the laughs!.Score: 5/5

This podcastWould be sooo much better without all the talking that has nothing to do with the story! Just get to the point, I hate having to fast forward 30-40mins in..Score: 1/5

Good, but fast forwardI love My Favorite Murder except for the fact that they spend 30-40 min of the podcast talking about everything else EXCEPT murder. Insane.Score: 3/5

Cool compliment fest, BUT...RE: the Laci Peterson case- lots of compliments given on the case coverage, BUT...not actually that great. There was zero mention of the newer defenses brought by Laci’s sister/Scott’s sister-in- law in an an effort to exonerate him. Whether she’s right or wrong, it’s pertinent and recent and merits at least a mention when covering this case in May of 2021. I know that actually doing new content might be strange and foreign after a year of quilt episodes, but they do get to it after the first 35 minutes of blah and ads, so one could hope they’d include a modicum of recent research. Also effort and attention to the current case status..Score: 2/5

SsdgmI love this podcast so much! Karen and Georgia has gotten me through so much..Score: 5/5

MFPMy favorite podcast.Score: 5/5

Tell us when the true crime startsStories and the telling are great but for the love of god, if it’s going to take 20+ minutes to get to the case, TELL US WHEN IT STARTS IN THE SHOW NOTES. not everyone is here for the chit chat.Score: 3/5

Fantastic show that is currently on some unspoken hiatusDark, twisted true-crime horror tales as told by two naturally hilarious and witty women who are just amazing. I cannot get enough! Edit: Two years later and this is still my all-time favorite podcast!!! Thank you for continuing to share this incredible show with us!! Edit: FOUR years later and these two keep producing the consistent material!! I am so grateful as a long-time fan that you all have had such immense, well-deserved success!! Also, THANK YOU for all you do!!! SSDGM!.Score: 5/5

AdsUsed to really enjoy listening but the sheer number of ads per episode make it a little hard to listen to if you can’t reach the skip button.Score: 4/5

EasyPeasyIt’s easy, I just love them..Score: 5/5

Used to be my favI used to love this podcasts but the last year, not so much. I understand it’s important to talk about mental illness but Georgia literally takes pride in her problems and makes everything about herself. It’s absurd. And “latchkey kid” is literally said in every single episode. Stop. You’re not cool because you have mental illness and it’s NOT a competition. Also the way they went about complaining about how hard their lives are/were during the pandemic. Like read. The. Room. No one wants to hear two rich women complain about their cushioned lives. It’s gross and weird and annoying. Absolutely over it and I typically wouldn’t take the time to write a review but since they have no respect for their listeners, I thought I should..Score: 2/5

My favorite podcast!I love y’all so much. Always looking forward to the next ep!.Score: 5/5

The bestIf you’re not listening, you’re missing out..Score: 5/5

SSDGM MF’ersThis podcast got me thru quarantine and beyond. These ladies are the bomb..Score: 5/5

GeniusI’ve been listening to this podcast for almost 4 years now. Over 4 years I’ve developed the best friends I never knew I needed, in a community I couldn’t feel more comfortable in. A side splitting and educational listen every week. I recommend to everyone when they’re just starting out listening to podcasts. Thank you all for the hard work you do. It’s gotten me though a lot. Congratulations on 5 years!.Score: 5/5

Get to the pointI wanted to start a new true crime podcast but it took so long for them to get to the story..Score: 1/5

Time stamp beginning of showI have listened to every episode of this podcast. Now that the hosts talk for no less than a half hour at the beginning of each show it would be awesome to time stamp in the description when the actual stories begin for those of us who don’t want to wade through more than 30 minutes of recommendations (which can be great of course but it would be helpful for when a listener wants to skip)..Score: 4/5

Absolute fave and always will be.I’ve been listening for years now. I know the pod has changed a bit, but I love everything the ladies do. I enjoy the banter. Makes me feel like I’m just catching up with friends. I will continue to listen and I doubt I will ever stop. ♥️.Score: 5/5

Used to be good.True crime is no longer the primary topic. I’ve listened for a long time but I just can’t anymore. All these quilt and live show repeats are very annoying. How in the world do you not have time to make new content, especially when you have researchers do the work? And even then, the research is sparse and stories aren’t very detailed. Lots of cringey virtue signaling in the -now way too long- intro conversation. And then somewhat disrespectful banter and laughter while discussing actual victims. I’m not opposed to their political views but goddamn guys, we know how you feel- move on to the stories!.Score: 2/5

SSDGM!Y’all are my favorite co-workers as I have worked from home this year:).Score: 5/5

Spark is goneI’m a longtime listener but for the past few months I’ve found myself skipping their new stuff altogether and going back to their old episodes. I get a lot had happened since then, but the spark is completely gone, it feels like K&G are just over it and going through the motions. The intros have gotten longer and longer and I often forget that this is supposed to be about true from and not everything else they discuss for what seems like forever. I thought initially I might be alone in this but in reading over recent reviews it’s clear other long time listeners feel the same. To be called “trolls” for voicing our opinions in hopes that the hosts will be receptive and make some much-needed changes is insulting..Score: 2/5

The two best friends you wish you hadI absolutely love this podcast! Karen and Georgia are the two best friends everyone wish you had. I am a true crime fanatic and although they add their own humor and chit chat along the way, their story telling abilities keep you coming back for more. Some people are annoyed by their side conversations but it keeps everything real and is a nice break from the heavy stories they tell. My Favorite Murder has been one of the few things keeping me going through this pandemic..Score: 5/5

Used to betterWas a huge fan, but I can’t listen anymore. Unsubscribed. I’ve seen them complaining about fans complaining about their lack of quality so I guess I’m the bad guy. Don’t mind the quilt eps; I just skip. Problem was the overly long intros and uneducated preaching. I’m liberal, but enough..Score: 1/5

Absolutely favorite podcast!As someone with dark humor and who has always had an interest in crime and murder stories, finally found the perfect podcast! This podcast has it all: twists, turns, dark humor, psychological support, and murder! My fellow murderino friend are always excited to talk about the most recent episodes..Score: 5/5

DisappointedI tried to hang in there but today I decided to unsubscribe. I miss the old days when the stories were interesting and the ladies had genuine passion for the podcast. Like many longtime fans, I’ve grown tired of quilt episodes, live show repeats (never liked live shows to begin with and definitely don’t want to hear them a second time) and the overall vibe between the ladies. I never minded the political views and banter in the beginning of the show but lately it has lost its spark. Quite honestly, I’m surprised the show even has a 4.5 rating..Score: 1/5

My friend got me hooked!I started listened to TPWKY in March of 2020 and I was telling a friend about it when she said, “THATS KAREN & GEORGIA’S NETWORK!” And she launched into how wonderful MFM is. Well it may have taken me a year to start listening but Karen & Georgia are great company no matter what I’m doing just like Erin & Erin are..Score: 5/5

Getting OldThis podcast is still pretty funny and entertaining, but all the political talk is getting old. Karen and Georgia seem to think that their audience isn’t politically diverse, or more likely don’t care because they constantly insult them with their bizarre scolding. And I almost didn’t make it through episode 225, because neither case covered was a murder. Both were just straight up pandering to the left. * Update as of 5/13/21: I have unsubscribed after the diatribe filled with false information regarding transgender bills (why this is in a true crime podcast is beyond me). Why would I bother listening anymore to a podcast whose hosts hate me and my beliefs that they actually know nothing about? Please educate yourselves and don’t believe everything the propaganda media tells you. Until then your podcast will continue to lose previously loyal listeners like me..Score: 1/5

MFM minisode 211WOW! Love the podcasts as well as the reading, viewing, listening suggestions! Might I suggest The Baroness von Sketch Show? These four Canadian comedians (all women) are hilarious. Check it out for free on Peacock..Score: 5/5

Lacks RespectThey seem only interested in giggling over horrible crimes rather than telling stories and possibly helping spread awareness or doing anything actually meaningful regarding these crimes. They don't research as well as they could and they talk about people in an inappropriate way. People have been horribly treated and they talk about it without a single ounce of respect. Laughing and telling jokes and acting like they're discussing a football team, rather than heinous crimes. The victims deserve better when telling their stories..Score: 1/5

I can’t do it anymoreToo much banter and not enough crime. I was an avid listener at one point, but things have gone down hill. I have to fast forward at least thirty minutes in order to get to the actual crime portion of the podcast. It’s incredibly disappointing that they don’t do their own research and constantly put out quilt episodes. There was a reason I never listened to live episodes in the past. I suggest you tune into Crime Junkie, or Morbid instead..Score: 1/5

Loved true crime before it was coolI have been watching g shows like Dateline and 48 Hours for as long as I can remember. When I heard about this podcast, I knew I wasn’t as weird as my family thought. The girls are so genuine and funny and they make these compelling stories come to life. Well done ladies..Score: 5/5

Still greatLove the banter.Score: 5/5

Mental Health Hero’sAll horrendous stories aside. These two wonderful humans have helped me process and unpack things that I never thought I could face. Woneful, brilliant and an absolute must!.Score: 5/5

Hands down, my favorite podcastI mean, obviously, the murder stories are engrossing, and you become invested, but beyond the murder stuff Georgia and Karen have become friends during a very isolating pandemic. Their witty banter, and willingness to openly discuss mental illness has made my days at home, normally lonely and isolating, seem like I’ve had an afternoon chatting with friends..Score: 5/5

Long introsIntros have gotten way too long - they should include the start time of the actual episode they are covering in the description ..Score: 1/5

ListenerI have been listening for as long as I can remember. I really wish Georgia would speculate less and just tell the story. It’s cringey. It seems like it has gotten worse over the past few months. I have increasingly started rolling my eyes more and more because sometimes I’m just not even sure what she is talking about..Score: 2/5

What’s even happeningI’ve been listening for years. You can tell Karen can barely tolerate Georgia’s nonsensical comments. Every time Georgia talks I’m just internally cringing because you can tell that she has no idea what she’s saying but somehow how she needs to make it about herself to stay relevant. Bring back the passion for the show or do us all a favor and just stop the podcast. It’s easy to just label bad reviews as trolls instead of what they really are...the truth..Score: 1/5

SO GOODThis podcast is so good that I literally binged all 500+ episodes in 2 months!.Score: 5/5

Laugh out loud funny!Look... listen... this podcast saved me. Karen and Georgia feel like good friends who aren’t afraid to address the importance of mental health, seeking help, taking care of yourself, while also offering an escape from the craziness of reality we all currently face. I often spit my drink out laughing some days and others start SCREAMING at the failures of our justice system. It’s a intimate combination of humor, education, public service announcements, passion for pets and pet heroes, charities we should be supporting, oh and occasionally brutal murder.... etc etc etc. I can’t get enough. Lately they have received negative feedback for recycling old episodes.... but I’ve absolutely adored them. I enjoy the live episodes as well. Karen Kilgariff is my favorite comedian of all time.... just saying. I always lock my doors now. Stay sexy and don’t miss out on this podcast!.Score: 5/5

I used to love this podcast but now...I don’t think I’m a murderino anymore. I’ve been listening to this podcast for many years and really enjoyed it. I recommended it to all my friends! Now , it’s rare I listen to it on the day it comes out and sometimes I just don’t at all. It used to be a true crime podcast and now it’s mostly about self help books, tv shows and the hosts personal therapy. As a therapist and someone who has already worked out my own mental health stuff, I came to the podcast for respite. It feels like work when I listen now and it’s not where I want to spend my free time . It used to be two good true crime stories with comedy sprinkled in. Now it’s one recording of a story from past live show after 45 minutes of self affirmations and love letters to their therapists. I’m very glad that they are seeking mental health treatment and they have overcome many issues but that is not the reason I listened to a podcast called “ my favorite murder” ..Score: 2/5

Long time listener no more...I’m so sad. I have LOVED this podcast from the beginning, I’ve been to 3 live shows, I have posters and T-shirt’s...but it’s not the same anymore. I never listen to the live/quilt episodes because they’re hard to listen to (sound quality and more jokey stories than actual true crime). I also am bored of the minisodes. I miss the quality episodes with well researched info, their banter, the catchphrases! It’s all kinda gone. I still love and support K & G and the podcast network but it seems they don’t still love and support the murderino community by providing well-done episodes. I also feel kinda hurt that they reference our feedback as being “trolls”...these are your longtime listeners trying to reach out, trying to provide helpful feedback & it seems like no one wants to listen. Unfortunately because of this reason I will be unsubscribing in hopes that maybe the decrease in subscription rates will finally prompt them to listen to their listeners qualms with the current quality/format. PLEASE!.Score: 1/5

Performanece Lab 🎯Performance Lab ® CORE Formulas support all aspects of human performance, across all walks of life. Boosts work performance and productivity with nootropics for focus, multitasking under stress, creative problem-solving and more. Buy Now!AdvertorialScore: 5/5

YOU GUYSStop worrying about doing one story a week and feeling like you need to explain yourselves! We love you and seriously do not mind - hearing from you once a week in any format has made 2020 bearable ❤️.Score: 5/5

Staying sexy and not getting murderedI really enjoy the pod and how when talking about a child one of you will say oh sweety oh hun, i find it very sweet. Though there are a couple things I hate. 1. Having to skip half an hour for the actual murder talk to start - excessive banter is not why we’re here! 2. The live shows - if you can’t do an episode that week, don’t stress! Other than that, you are amazing! Just please cut down on the banter before episodes, maybe even have it after the episode? Or put in the comments the time when the actually podcast starts?.Score: 4/5

Excellent!I listen to this in small chunks as I am afraid of everything but Karen and Georgia are so adorable and their friendship is such a treat that I listen anyway. And I’ve taught my Pilates class SSDGM, so thanks for that!.Score: 5/5

Favourite or Favorite podcast?My sis has been on about mfm for years. I tried to find it but couldn’t about a year later she reminded me Americans spell favourite without the U. We don’t want U in my favorite murder do we now? I’m listening to about mfm approx. 3 hours a day and hanging to get to 2021 but currently stuck in 2017. Thank you for making house cleaning, walking the dog, long drives and even food shopping more enjoyable while I giggle and gasp to myself in the frozen food isle with my ear buds in. Lol SSDGM xox Aussie Amy.Score: 5/5

My Favourite PodcastLove these two ladies, the best thing to listen to every week..Score: 5/5

My Favourite PodcastThe most amazing women, incredible topics, hilarious and sometimes deep conversations. If your on the fence with listening I have to say do it 100%, SSDGM!.Score: 5/5

My most listened to podcastLove these girls. They’re the best. So interesting. Please never stop making it.Score: 5/5

The O.G. True Crime boss ladiesFeels like hanging out with two of my besties when I listen to each episode — these gals are funny, kind and just so badass! Look forward to it each week!.Score: 5/5

Amaaaaazing!Live live love this podcast! The chicks are funny and really well researched and basically it feels like your listening in on a chat with your besties! As I’m from Australia I would love to hear more Australian Murder stories please ☺️ You’re doing an awesome job - stay sexy and keep up the good spirits through the pandemic!!! Many thanks Jacqui from Queensland.Score: 5/5

Everything I needThis is one of if not the only the only podcast I don’t get sick of and delete. The mix of interesting stories told from all angles, the humour of their day to day lives and the reminder/open talk of therapy and bettering ourselves is all wrapped up in this. You honestly feel like you’re chatting to your friends whilst being drawn in to some insanely intriguing murders. Thank you for keeping me and many other company on our rides, walks and work days! SSDGM.Score: 5/5

Longtime listener, forever MurderinoKaren and Georgia’s approach to true crime is right up my alley - it’s honest, it’s brutal at times, but they always humanise the experience for the listener. The quotable nature of this podcast is insane and the community is incredible. So if you want to be apart of a funny yet eye opening chat about true crime, get ready to sit crooked and talk straight..Score: 5/5

BingeworthyI feel very grateful that I only discovered my love for this podcast a few years after they started making it. I spent my 2020 listening to every episode whilst working on my sewing projects. There are very few podcasts I could listen to for 8 hours straight but this is one of them! Since catching up I’ve been struggling to find something as engaging and interesting, might just have to restart MFM..Score: 5/5

AddictiveThe only podcast I have ever stuck with. It took me a few episodes to get into it, but I have now heard every episode ever and “save” episodes for myself as rewards for runs. For fans of true crime, neurotic anxiety humour, and cult classic in-jokes!.Score: 5/5

Previously wrote a bad reviewJust wanted to change my previous review and apologise. I’m sorry for being an a hole. Keep up the good work and please look after yourself..Score: 5/5

A trillion stars!Aside from great stories, they are open, honest, hilarious and refreshingly human, qualities we are lacking as a society right now. I love that I know their political views and respect them all the more for this transparency..Score: 5/5

Used to love itI’ve just had to skip through 38 minutes of inane chatter to get to the actual story of the latest episode. They used to be great but now they’re so self righteous in their opinions and ~psychoanalysis~ of murderers when they have no actual qualifications. The talking at the start is just getting longer and longer and about quarantine and I’m in Australia so can’t relate to not being able to leave the house, they forget it’s an international audience. Will still listen to the minisodes because the unrelated chat is less but the longer episodes are getting insufferable.Score: 2/5

Love itLove it.Score: 5/5

Avid ListenerI have been listening for the last two years and I am currently re-listening to the podcast from scratch. I’ve never reviewed the show but after reading some flack the amazingly funny, kind, considerate and supportive women had received I finally sat to write this down. Excellent show. Has helped me immensely with being alert and aware of my surroundings and also helped with the anxiety and stress of a phd. It’s therapeutic to listen to Karen and Georgia be vulnerable, relatable, funny and simply amazing storytellers to such horrific and sad stories. Yet they are respectful and considerate to the victims! Love it. Look forward to it..Score: 5/5

Y’allThe banter is my favourite part...Score: 5/5

Lots of good episodesThe back catalogue is great. Recently the podcast feels it’s moved away from true crime to just waffling on. Not being negative as hours and hours of great episodes but the lately it’s not for me.Score: 4/5

Love foreverI love Karen and Georgia so much. They are funny and insightful and get better and better each week!.Score: 5/5

Hey GirlsListening from Sydney Australia and upon your word, rated, liked & subscribed. I’m now writing the review in which I share your podcast with all my friends and fam. I think your humour mixed with the insane topics make listening more consumable and thank you for being so funny and beautiful in the ugly world of murder..Score: 5/5

Start with the early epsI’ve been following along since the first eps a few years ago and I reckon if you’re picking this one up, start from there. Last year or so the magic has been lost. They’ve kinda sold out. Which I get , I’d be chasing the bucks too. It’s just that they seem so bored doing it..Score: 3/5

Holds a mirror to our society?Karen and Georgia are entertainment professionals and know how to spin a yarn. It’s accompanied by a lot of vulnerability and graciousness, but don’t be fooled. This is a show of outstanding quality and commentary of our culture..Score: 5/5

Long time listener, first time reviewerLove ❤️.Score: 5/5

Must listenLove the pre-murder banter and the ladies! My absolute favourite podcast.Score: 5/5

Love this pod.I have been listening for years and can’t wait every week for a new ep. Georgia and Karen share highs and lows and you really feel like you’re having a chat with your friends..Score: 5/5

Too much banterReally annoying to have to fast forward FORTY minutes into an episode before they even start talking about the case. Wouldn’t be a problem but the banter is not funny or interesting. Super frustrating. Maybe include in the description the time the case actually starts so people can fast forward?.Score: 2/5

My best friendsHave listened from the beginning (5+ years ago now) and haven’t made the time to rate & review until now. I’ve learned so much from this podcast, about myself, about mental health, personal safety, red flags and more. I also now NEVER ignore that feeling in my gut that tells me something is wrong. Love staying sexy with Karen and Georgia!.Score: 5/5

So hard to listen to nowThis pod used to be great. Then they got lazy. Then they got arrogant. Now they’re just sad. Flaming bad reviews without redacting names and siccing your cult onto them is just dirty. I would say you should quit while you’re ahead but that ship passed a LONG time ago..Score: 1/5

Long time listener first time reviewer!I have listened since episode 19 and am still an avid listener after all these years. I personally enjoy the banter at the start of the episodes which makes it feel like chatting and gossiping with old friends. Not a huge fan of quilt episodes as I’ve already listened to all other eps but other than that these ladies are fantastic and well and truly still have it!.Score: 5/5

Love them!!Best part of the week for sure.Score: 5/5

This show is still the best out there!Boo to all the naysayers! These ladies do a FABULOUS job and their opening banter and sharing about tv shows and books is all worth it! These two have kept the faith in a crazy time and stayed home when others didn’t. We didn’t have to experience the horror of Trump and the trauma of Covid in Queensland, Australia but the few lockdowns that we have had, made me super depressed. I listen to Karen and Georgia and feel like I’m with friends. Love everything about this amazing podcast - it has become an absolute bond between my 24 year old daughter and I..Score: 5/5

My favourite banterLove the chats, the realness and the stories..Score: 5/5

I UnsuscribedAfter being a fan & subscriber for years I am finally tapping out. The intent of the show has shifted away from its original true crime sharing to just waffling on about themselves. I use to really enjoy the story telling aspect of this, but now its just opinion & little true crime aspect..Score: 2/5

Disappointed long time fanI’ve unsubscribed. Reading book reports written by someone else is disappointing..Score: 1/5

Is this a crime podcast???Little coverage of actual crime. More personal arbitrary opinions and passing judgements..Score: 1/5

Exactly WrongSadly, the girls have really dropped the ball. This used to be my go-to, all time favourite podcast but now... it’s like they can’t be bothered? We don’t wanna hear 40 minutes of what movies and tv shows you’ve been watching, only to then get a half assed attempt at covering a murder that you clearly have no interest in. Such a shame as these girls used to rule the true crime podcast world - not anymore..Score: 2/5

Hearing old friendsI started at the beginning and have worked through all the episodes (as have my sister and best friend!) and while the show has changed, and Karen and Georgia have changed and grown and learnt there is a core of excitement, friendship and sharing that has not changed. The show is not a straight recap of true crime as it once was, but I enjoy how Karen and Georgia have embraced change, and I am happy to see a podcast willing to change and grow as the hosts do. An excellent show, very much like having a weekly chat up with old friends. We don’t always agree, but I always walk away happy..Score: 5/5

The bestListening to these ladies always relaxes me.Score: 5/5

LoveMy favourite podcast!.Score: 5/5

The good 'ol daysI recommend this podcast to anyone who will listen and have been listening for years, however I won't be recommending any more. It seems as though the show has become more about what Karen and Georgia think and feel about various, random subjects as opposed to murders and murder investigations. My husband just turned the last podcast off saying "Jaysus Christ this has become "my favourite mundane story". When we feel like a hit of MFM, we'll be scrolling back to 2018/2019. Hope you get your spark back girls..Score: 3/5

My fave crime podcastLong time listener, and it’s time I rated. I regularly listen to a dozen podcasts and this is a fave. This is story telling with a touch of humanity and levity. It feels like a chat over a glass of wine with close girlfriends. Thanks, from Perth Australia (that’s to remind you to come here one day)!.Score: 5/5

Sigh.Late to the party, I binged from first episode about 18 months ago.. now I eagerly await the next episode each week. Lately, I’ve been feeling a little disappointed after each episode. I don’t mind the chatter before hand.. but something is missing. The true crime is missing. I’m not reviewing this to complain, but rather to just provide honest feedback and hopefully constructive criticism! I enjoy the banter prior, but I can’t help but think with all the books, shows and movies you mention you’ve spent the last week or so catching up on, binging etc, that you haven’t left the house for X amount of time, it’s a bit of a slap in the face to get a lack lustre story. Could that time not be spent researching a new story? Also bring back the days when there were two stories. I appreciate that it may require more time and effort, however, you were able to do it once, more than likely with less resources and less support. I really enjoy what you guys have done but I get the feeling your hearts are no longer in it. And that’s ok, that happens! It’s understandable and the natural cycle. Ask yourselves, are you doing the best you can? do you even want to anymore? Is there room for growth or improvement? SSDGM.Score: 2/5

Long time fanI am a long time fan. I’m a bit younger and have been listening since I was about twelve when they first started out (had to stop for a bit but I’m back) I have listened to every episode some more than once and I love it..Score: 5/5

The bestBeen listening for four years now and it just keeps getting better.Score: 5/5

A great podcastI was late finding this podcast. I have listened from episode one and just caught up to present day,today. I’m so annoyed that I have to wait for a new episode now! A great podcast compromising of an interesting story, and relevant and amusing discussion. The community that has resulted from this podcast is a great reflection of the hosts’ delivery. They’re so down to earth and honest about human nature that it resonates with the listener and makes you feel like part of the discussion, while reassuring you that you have like-minded people everywhere to connect with. The stories are truely fascinating and told with grace and humour to reassure you that fascination does not equal appreciation of the crime. I love how they really focus on the victims and make sure their stories are heard and continue to be queried..Score: 5/5

Seriously if you don’t listen to this already what are you doing?It’s the perfect podcast! It’s smart, funny and spooky. What else do you want?.Score: 5/5

Love these two!I have been listening to this podcast for years and these two are in my inner circle of friends even though they don’t know that. I love how real they are and not afraid to talk openly about their mental health as well as our fascination with true crime. Love them!.Score: 5/5

Hang out with friendsI’ve listened from the beginning and I love how far they’ve come and I never want them to stop making this <3.Score: 5/5

Coursera 💡Start your future on coursera today! Build skills with courses, certificates, and degrees online from world-class universities and companies. Join for Free!AdvertorialScore: 5/5

AirBNB 🎁Get $64 off on your first stay at travels. Claim your $64 Airbnb free credit by clicking here!AdvertorialScore: 5/5

My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark Podcast Episodes

MFM Minisode 227

This week’s hometowns include a creepy neighbor story and a haunted university.  See for privacy information.

274 - Arrested Behavior

On this week’s episode, Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Laci Peterson. See for privacy information.

MFM Minisode 226

This week’s hometowns include a criminal-chasing mom and a postal worker hero. See for privacy information.

My Favorite Murder Presents: The True Beauty Brooklyn Podcast - "Pivoting During a Pandemic, Inclusive Luxury Beauty Brands, & Love Your Hair with Sabrina Rowe"

My Favorite Murder presents the network premiere episode of The True Beauty Brooklyn Podcast on Exactly Right! Hosts Alix Shapiro & Elizabeth Taylor kick off their launch the same way they started their show one year ago -- interviewing one of their dearest friends, resident hair and beauty guru SABRINA ROWE. Sabrina is the founder of the inclusive, sustainable, luxury beauty brand NTRL by Sabs (pronounced "natural"), and is a celebrity hair and makeup artist to clients like Phoebe Robinson, Ilana Glazer, Uzo Aduba and more.  Listen and subscribe to The True Beauty Brooklyn Podcast on Apple Podcasts, Stitcher, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts.  See for privacy information.

273 - Live at the Arlene Schnitzer Concert Hall in Portland (2018)

On this week’s former Fan Cult exclusive episode, Karen and Georgia cover murderer Christian Longo and the KOIN Tower hostage situation. See for privacy information.

MFM Minisode 225

This week’s hometowns include a dartboard and a Marty story. See for privacy information.

272 - BYOF

In this week’s quilt episode, Karen and Georgia cover The Beast of Birkenshaw and the mysterious legend of D.B. Cooper. See for privacy information.

MFM Minisode 224

This week’s hometowns include a mace story and a pen-based murder. See for privacy information.

271 - 4 Hours of Sacred Pausing

On this week’s episode, Karen and Georgia cover Sophie Scholl & the White Rose youth resistance, and the survival story of Ada Blackjack. See for privacy information.

Easy Hits

My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark Similar Podcasts

My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark podcast
My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia HardstarkExactly Right06 May 2021True Crime517 EpisodesFREE
This Podcast Will Kill You podcast
This Podcast Will Kill YouExactly Right04 May 2021Life Sciences92 EpisodesFREE
The Purrrcast podcast
The PurrrcastExactly Right05 May 2021Society & Culture303 EpisodesFREE
Do You Need A Ride? podcast
Do You Need A Ride?Exactly Right03 May 2021Comedy Interviews176 EpisodesFREE
I Said No Gifts! podcast
I Said No Gifts!Exactly Right06 May 2021Comedy61 EpisodesFREE
Bananas podcast
BananasExactly Right04 May 2021Comedy66 EpisodesFREE
Hide Your Identity!
Brain Force
Free Website Traffic
Faster Hosting
You were invited to try Coinbase!Coinbase is the world's most trusted place to buy and sell cryptocurrency. Open an account today, and if you buy or sell $100 or more of crypto, you'll receive $10 worth of free Bitcoin!