Murder With My Husband podcast

Murder With My Husband

0 star

On this episode of MWMH, Payton and Garrett discuss the abduction and murder of 16-year-old Mickie. Case Sources: Dateline episode Links: Ads: HydroJug: and use code: HUSBAND Raycon: - 15% off Best Fiends HelloFresh: and use code husband14 for up to 14 free meals, plus free shipping! Sarah Flint: Magic Spoon: use code HUSBAND SundanceNow: use code HUSBAND Olive and June: use code HUSBAND Learn more about your ad-choices at

Murder With My Husband Podcast Comments

What do you think about Murder With My Husband podcast? Ask the community a question about Murder With My Husband!

Please wait! Murder With My Husband podcast comments loading...

Murder With My Husband Podcast Reviews

Love this podcast.Up there with one of the best podcasts around. Love true crime and love the way Peyton tells the stories. 🙌🏼🙌🏼 From Cardiff, Wales 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿.Score: 5/5

All the Way from Yorkshire UKLove your Podcasts, absolutely hooked, have you thought of doing any UK murders? Keep it up , loving it.Score: 5/5

Best podcast goingListen from Norfolk England and love it, keep It going guys.Score: 5/5

Can’t stop listening!I found this podcast by chance through a reel on IG and boy am I glad!?! They cover very interesting cases and have a way of storytelling that’s so enthralling! MWMH is going to BLOW UP so soon and you both deserve it so much :).Score: 5/5

Love it !I have become addicted to your stories , and actually made my husband listen to them !! You guys are great !👏🏽👏🏽.Score: 5/5

One of the best podcast!Only came across this podcast not too long ago and i am obsessed with it they are so intriguing to listen too, sending love from scotland! you should definitely listen to them such great people.Score: 5/5

I’m shook.I can’t explain to you how much I enjoyed your podcast. I found you on tiktok first, but spent the past week devouring your content on Apple podcast and YouTube. I’m not going to lie, I’m genuinely terrified of everything right now including my own shadow but I throughly enjoyed listening. I watched all 79 episodes and some cases will haunt me till this day. I love Payton storytelling, sometime I gasp with Garrett because I genuinely did not expect that ending or the victim to survive. Some cases are very eerie and I cannot believe we live in a world with such frightening people. Episode 49 and 36 will definitely stick with me. There are so many good episodes! Love from England 😘.Score: 5/5

AddictedI absolutely love this podcast!! I have listened to almost all of them within a week.Score: 5/5

Love itI’m addicted very good show.Score: 5/5

So many advertsNot a bad podcast but, oh my goodness, so many adverts, with really technically jarring transitions, it’s almost unlistenable. We can’t all afford to be patreons..Score: 2/5

Great podcastNeed to this but I’m hooked! Seem to be working backwards😆 have you or would you cover any British murders?.Score: 5/5

OBSESSED 😂After finding you on YouTube I binged every single episode on there and then came here to get the earlier ones! Can’t stop listening, the best true crime podcast I have found by far and I even got my partner of 3 years to listen and he hates true crime but is now asking me if we can listen to you guys so Thankyou for that! Lots of love, Newcastle, England 🇬🇧.Score: 5/5

My favourite podcast ever!!!!!Firstly the amount of time and work you can see that Payton puts in to creating these podcasts is absolutely amazing, you can see she cares and wants to make the podcast as amazing as she can. I love how Payton credits all of her resources she uses which I don’t see on a lot of other podcasts I listen to and I also love how respectful and compassionate she is to the victims and families/friends involved in the cases, it is really appreciated. Garrett is also so warm and friendly and adds such a nice touch to the podcast, they seem like the warmest, friendliest and most appreciative couple. I found there podcast from Tik tok and can’t reccomend enough and I’m so glad glad I found them! This has to be the best true crime podcast I listen to and I listen to a lot! Keep up the great work guys :).Score: 5/5

An amazing Pod castLove love love these, keep me occupied on my longs drives! Cheers guys!.Score: 5/5

ObsessedFound you guys on TikTok and haven’t stop listening since love you guys and love that you do a lot of cases I’ve never heard of! Love from the UK🤍.Score: 5/5

To many advertsWas a good podcast in the early days but now far to many adverts. I have now stopped listening to this. 5 adverts for a 20 - 30 min podcast is a bit over the top..Score: 1/5

Phenomenal PodcastAmazing podcast always see these stories in short form on tik tok or Instagram great to listen to the full stories with all the information, and Garrett and Payton are both very loveable so it makes for a great listening experience.Score: 5/5

Binge listened to all!!Loved listening to all these! Started listening as I also find it really interesting as to why some1 would want to murder etc. Binge listened to all episodes in 2 weeks… listening all the way from England UK.Score: 5/5

Five starGreat find. Would definitely recommend you listen to these 2. Great storytelling and great mix of well known and unknown cases.Score: 5/5

Great podcastLove these podcasts listen to them all the time while working out. Glasgow listener, keep up the amazing work..Score: 5/5

Great findHaving run out of True Crime podcasts to binge on, I was delighted to come across this great podcast. Really enjoying them. (UK).Score: 5/5

Great PodcastJust 1 comment, please understand Italy and Spain are in Europe..Score: 5/5

Incredible PodcastFinally fully caught up and wow this is by far my favourite podcast..Score: 5/5

Love it 😊Just discovered you both and it is by far the best one ,you’re storytelling has me hooked with the content and warmth with each episode ,very happy uk listener 🇬🇧.Score: 5/5

Amazing!Such a good podcast 😄.Score: 5/5

Insightful and sensitiveMy husband introduced me to this show - I love the subject matter, he generally hates this sort of thing - but now we sometimes listen to this podcast together in bed instead of reading our books! Really love this podcast - very insightful and deals with some difficult content with a great deal of sensitivity. From your English fans x.Score: 5/5

Binge worthy!I love listening and even watching this podcast on YouTube when doing anything! Grocery shopping, laundry watching my daughter at horse club. You name it! Love that the husband ask question that someone who doesn’t know the case already would ask. Amazing!!.Score: 5/5

This podcast has made cleaning fun!Stumbled across you with your snippet videos on TikTok, absolutely love the podcast and I put it on for hours whilst I’m cleaning or cooking! Not sure what I will do once i get to just one a week! Dirty house I guess!.Score: 5/5

Love it! But please no background musicGuys I love your podcast but please don’t play sound effects for the Halloween ghost stories..I jumped out of my seat and spilled my hot coffee.. Thanks Nyeema x.Score: 2/5

I really likeI like it because there are really good story’s and facts 🇬🇧🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿.Score: 5/5

Something newI have been looking for something true crime for ages, so happy I have found this! So many episodes to binge on! Thank from sunny Scotland!.Score: 5/5

So glad I found this!Really love this podcast! So glad my other half showed me them on Tik Tok. I really enjoy the dynamic and that Garrett is almost like a member of the audience, asking questions or saying what we are thinking whilst listening..Score: 5/5

Absolutely love this podcast!I’ve recently started listening to podcasts but honestly since discovering murder with my husband I haven’t stopped listening! I love it!.Score: 5/5

AmazingSo interesting to listen too, I find her voice so soothing! You won’t regret downloading this podcast.Score: 5/5

Absolutely amazing!Can’t stop listening to this podcast. I can’t remember a day in the last few months that I haven’t been listening to these over and over again! Love the show, keep up the good work!.Score: 5/5

All they care about is moneyI used to love your podcast because of how humble you seemed and just wanted to talk About true crime, now an ad every five minutes makes it unbearable to listen ! Can tell they only care about money now , don’t even care what they are promoting as long as they get paid. Very disappointing We all understand you want to make a living but you’ve lost your integrity now 1 ad at the beginning , middle and end is enough stop being greedy and ruining your podcast Quickest way to lose listeners and in turn lose sponsorship.Score: 2/5

A delightful podcastThis is such a lovely podcast. Payton is so enthusiastic and Garrett is so beautifully oblivious to everything true crime related. They are both very respectful and there is no cursing. Payton clearly works incredibly hard in researching each episode and I’m very much looking forward to seeing this podcast grow & truly hope that Payton manages to make it her full time job. I love the music they use too. He’s the husband ❤️. UK listener.Score: 5/5

Addicted!Love listening to these while I’m working in the office. (Although it got to a tense part and my boss tapped me on the shoulder and I screamed 😂😂) people complain about the adverts but they really aren’t that bad! Would love for you to feature some notorious British murders e.g the Jeremy Bamber case!.Score: 5/5

Too many adverts nowWas fab but far too many adverts now.Score: 3/5

Do not like the placement of the addsI used to love this podcast. Now with the adds every 5-10 minutes it's awful to listen to, a big distraction from the story. Much better to have a block of 3-4 minutes of adds in the middle..Score: 1/5

HookedNever listened to a podcast before my daughter Amy told me to listen to MWMH .. OMG I LOVE IT!! I’m hooked and listening from the first episode. I’m now upto 54 and they are fantastic, I’m binging 5/6 a day while getting ready for work, driving to work and doing my housework, excellent. I’ve even got my friend into listening… keep it up guys From the UK 🇬🇧.Score: 5/5

ObsessedAbsolutely love the podcast, they go into so much detail and really show respect for the victims. Great hosts! UK listener 💜.Score: 5/5

ItThis podcast is so interesting and has really good information on these story’s. From England 🇬🇧🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿.Score: 5/5

AmazingI found you guys in TikTok a while back haven’t stopped listening I have had my pod cast on every day since!.Score: 5/5

Love itJust found this and started from the beginning - 70 episodes to catch up on which I thought would take a while but hooked and binged 4 episodes and now it’s late and I’ll be tired at work tomorrow….worth it 🙂 Great job guys.Score: 5/5

Love it!My favourite podcast! I’m listening to rhem all the time :D.Score: 5/5

I am hookedBest crime podcast out ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️.Score: 5/5

Brilliant!Absolutely love this podcast. Found you guys on TikTok an I’m addict! Payton is amazing at telling all the facts. An listening to Garrett, is like us listeners voice us being heard. He asks the questions that all the listeners are also asking. It’s amazing!.Score: 5/5

Amazing podcastI came across your account on TikTok. I’ve never liked true crime but there’s something about this one that drew me in and I have been listening to them all from the beginning. I really love how well researched the cases are. I have it on in the background as I work. I’m on ep45 and every episode has been brilliant so far. Keep it up!! Much love from Scotland x.Score: 5/5

Best true crime podcastEach week is amazing! Wish we could have them daily because I love them that much! Amazing guys, keep up the good work!!.Score: 5/5

Free International Money Transfer 💸Enjoy high maximum transfers into more than 20 currencies while saving up to 90% over local banks! The cheap, fast way to send money abroad. Free transfer up to 500 USD!AdvertorialScore: 5/5

Love itI listening every day and I love it. It’s so addictive,keep killing it..Score: 5/5

The best!My fave podcast! Well done!!.Score: 5/5

GREAT SHOWI love listening to this podcast I’ve listened to many times your guys voices are chefs kiss and just make it interesting to listen. I listen at work while doing the grave yard shift :).Score: 5/5

Love love loveCurrently roadtripping with my boyfriend and every time we get in the car he asks to put on the ‘murder’ lol!! love this pod.Score: 5/5

Best request from a co-worker!Had this podcast requested to me by a co-worker and now I want to binge listen to all the eps! Lol But i must refrain because i like to listen to the podcast while i work! It helps me get through the day. Currently on eps5..Score: 5/5

Binge worthy!!!Love this podcast! I listed to all the episodes in a week and am so sad to be caught up and have to wait a week between episodes!.Score: 5/5

Used to love this podcastI used to love this podcast but it’s annoying that there are 3 ads within the 30 min podcast..Score: 1/5

Used to love the showI love the show and I love the used to be 5 stars! I loved it in the beginning with no ads. I know they need ads to continue but not enough content ratio to ads now. I’ll keep listening but I suggest limiting number of ads in relation to actual content time..Score: 3/5

The best!!Great podcast. Payton is a great storyteller and does a fabulous job with her research and she shows amazing compassion for the victims and always presents a fair and unbiased viewpoint. Garrett is so sweet and supportive. My new favourite podcast!!.Score: 5/5

MWMHAwesome podcast! The stories are always unbiased and well written, and they always included their sources for the info. Love listening to this podcast👍.Score: 5/5

BEST TRUE CRIME PODCAST !!!I love this podcast, Payton and Garret are brilliant. I listen to podcasts all day at the office and MWMH is my all time favourite. You guys rock, keep up the amazing work. PS. Payton, I think it’s time to bump up Garrets 10 seconds to 60 seconds now? he cracks me up..Score: 5/5

Love this Podcast!!Very entertaining and it keeps you busy engaged throughout the episode!.Score: 5/5

Love it!Makes my jaw drop every time! So good I love it!.Score: 5/5

Well call me a fish because I’m hooked.This podcast is brilliant and highly addictive! I drive around a lot for work and this is now my go to every time I get a chance to listen, I am hooked..Score: 5/5

Too many adsI really enjoyed this podcast but today I get three ads in a half hour show. No thank you!.Score: 2/5

Epidosde 65I am from BC and live in Victoria on Vancouver Island. I actually know the younger sister of A. Joesbury. It's scary to think this happened soo close to home!.Score: 5/5

Just The Best!Literally this podcast is the only one I listen too and is the whole reason I have Podcasts on my phone 😅. Started from the beginning, and making my way to the top. I love listening to these true crime story’s!.Score: 5/5

Such an amazing podcastI finished listening to all of the episodes in almost a week, and I look forward every week for a new episode, if you want to listen to an amazing podcast you’ve come to the right place.Score: 5/5

Positively AddictiveLove, love, love this podcast!!! I go for solo mom walks so I get my fill every night! 🤣 keep up the juicy work, folding laundry and washing dishes is finally exciting 😆 podcast while I mom.Score: 5/5

Way too many adsI really like the podcast and the way cases are presented but there’s so many ads I just can’t deal with it anymore. It’s not great to get really into the case and what’s happening then have to listen to multiple 2+minute ads, even in shorter episodes..Score: 2/5

SuperbeA great story teller & wonderful listener..Score: 5/5

Best PodcastHonestly my favourite podcast!! Keep it up guys ❤️❤️.Score: 5/5

Loveeeee this podcastI have officially listens to every episode!!.Score: 5/5

Fantastic true crime podcastPayton and Garrett are such a loveable couple! They naturally vibe with each other and it really makes the whole thing work. Great content quality and insight as well!.Score: 5/5

Great podcast … the ads though 🤦‍♀️Great podcast. I like the back and forth and the research…but my GOD the ADS! I know you can skip…but they are so frequent. I understand d making money, but it’s more ads than any podcast I’ve ever listened to. Still recommend!.Score: 4/5

Binge worthy 🙌🏼Came across this podcast this past week and have been listening every spare minute I have!! You guys are awesome! Love the story telling and reactions!.Score: 5/5

The best true crime podcast not kidding!!I love true crime but I’m SO picky about podcasts. This one is by far my favourite I’ve ever found! I’ve been listening non stop!.Score: 5/5

Favorite true crime podcastI’m addicted. You’re both awesome. Keep it up.Score: 5/5

Cant stop listening!I honestly fell in love with this podcast with only listening to one episode. I then turned my husband on to it and we ask each other often which episode we’ve listened to! We’ve been listening daily since we discovered Payton and Garrett! We love you guys!.Score: 5/5

Interesting CasesDefinitely worth a listen. I listen to a lot of true crime podcasts and really enjoy this one for the most part. I will say that it can get pretty descriptive and Peyton tends to deep dive into the gruesome details, which I don’t think is entirely necessary..Score: 3/5

I am OBSESSEDI discovered this postcast about a month ago and have been absolutely obsessed since then. The episodes are the perfect length, and Peyton tells the stories so well. She takes time to honour the victims, while also exploring the nuances and details of each case in a detailed and respectful manner. Every time a new episode is dropped I am so excited to tune in..Score: 5/5

AMAZINGI can’t get enough of this, makes you feel like you’re just a couple of friends chatting about murder 😂 highly recommend!.Score: 5/5

Listened for joke now the only podcast I listen toThe narrators of the story tell it very well.Score: 5/5


G1I listen to crime a lot. First time I heard this, impressive.Score: 5/5

So good !This podcast is really good, I literally listen every day..Score: 5/5

Love itI burned through this so fast and am sad to be caught up..Score: 5/5

Thank you TikTokLOOL when you find your new favourite podcast on TikTok 😂😂.Score: 5/5

My favourite!!I listen to you guys every night as i fall sleep ❤️.Score: 5/5

My favorite podcast😍😍I used to be scared of true crime before but its explained so well that ur not scared but so invested in the stories🤩.Score: 5/5

My favourite podcast!Love this podcast! I listen to it on my drive to work (and sometimes on my way home too)! Payton is so well spoken and explains things so clearly I can just listen and enjoy! Great job guys! So happy I found this podcast!.Score: 5/5

AddictingLove this podcast! I’m so addicted. I like that each episode starts and finishes (for the most part) one case..Score: 5/5

ObsessedMy husband and I are obsessed with this podcast! It is our go to for road trips, random drives and late nights. Please never stop! ♥️.Score: 5/5

Love, Love, LoveI found this podcast on TikTok and I love it, I listen to this everyday and I’m OBSESSED. Keep up the good work guys!!.Score: 5/5

Best true crime podcast!!I love listening to this couple! They are so easy to listen to and Payton does such a good job researching and giving justice to the victims. I have listened to all their episodes and can’t wait for new ones! Thank you both for the hard work you put into these and keep them coming!.Score: 5/5

Love!Love this pod cast. I listen on the way to work and back everyday!.Score: 5/5

Love love loveI am OBSESSED with this podcast. I binged this podcast in just over two weeks. I learned so much and even giggled. I cannot wait to see what the next cases will be. Highly recommend to everyone and anyone who likes true crime. Well done Payton and Garrett!.Score: 5/5

The best true crime podcast!I stumbled upon a Tiktok clip as the Gabby Petito case is going viral. This led me to the poscast where I’ve quickly binge-listened to 50 episodes in a week! Working my way backwards through every episode and I’m addicted!.Score: 5/5

Love it!Intriguing and interesting … and possibly a drinking game every time garret says “what in the world” , “no way” or “oh my god”..Score: 5/5

Way WAY too many ads per episode 😵‍💫😵‍💫My god🤬🤬🤬 I had such high hopes for you guys but in one episode there has been 5 damn ads. 5!!!! And I didn’t even finish the episode to find out how many more. What a sellout. That’s WAY too many and far too annoying so that’s it for me. Good luck going forward. I truly hope you do something about it!.Score: 1/5

Payoneer 💰Payoneer is an online payment platform that lets you transfer money from any corner of the world! A best and must have payment service for every blogger, traveler, freelancer, affiliate marketer, consultant, virtual assistant, business person, online sellers, and receivers. Earn $25 for free by joining Payoneer. Sign Up Now!AdvertorialScore: 5/5

So goodThis is my favorite podcast. Especially for true crime. They tell the story so well and not glorifying it but getting the victims side out there and talking about who they were before they were a victim. I also love that they don’t do a bunch of filler talk that feels like inside jokes that only if you go back to the beginning would you understand. They also sprinkle in inspiring survivor stories. Some of my favorite episodes are those..Score: 5/5

Love love lovePayton does such a good job telling these stories and being respectful to the families and victims. I love Payton and Garrett’s relationship..Score: 5/5

Love love love!I stumbled across this on the TikTok but since it was only three minutes or so I wanted more! I was so happy to find the podcast. I have been bingeing it ever since. I love it. Thank you guys for all the work you put in.Score: 5/5

Best. podcast. ever.I usually need to watch videos because of my attention span. and i don’t need to watch videos for this podcast. i watch both youtube and listen to them. LOVE THEM SO MUXH!!!.Score: 5/5

My favorite podcast everHaven’t been able to find a true crime podcast I enjoy as much as this one.. Payton makes sure to do her research and Garrett makes the podcast so relatable and fun! MWMH is the best.Score: 5/5

Great!I love this podcast. I’ve listened to all of them! I only wish it was a little less scripted. I love the moments when they go off script and banter for a minute or on a little random tangent. But they are few and far between, so I wish there was more of that… I guess I wish there was more of them! More of their personality/relationship. Maybe a little more feedback from Garrett. Either way, there’s a lot of really great things about this podcast. I like how much research she does and they way she presents the info. I won’t stop listening anytime soon and can’t wait for another! *also, it bugs me when they don’t specify that they are going into an ad! Payton will say something gruesome, and then all of a sudden will start talking about skin care routine! lol it’s gotten better recently, but either an intro to the ad or music or something else would be appreciated.Score: 4/5

Binge watched in a week✨I love the podcast! Only feedback would be to please, go into detail. I have to know everything. I keep looking up all the details lol. Oh and put the husband’s catch phrase on merch. “That’s crazy!”.Score: 5/5

Junko furutaYou should make one on junko furuta.Score: 5/5

Love, BUT..Love you guys, good quick detailed stories and fun to listen to. However, in the maybe ten episodes I’ve listened to you mispronounced like 7 major places. Maybe take some time to learn how to properly pronounce cities before you tell the story? Pretty quick and easy thing to do. (New Orleans and St. Louis for example).Score: 5/5

Trying really hard to ignore the accents and blatant ignorance sometimesThis is fun. But maybe use sources that aren’t youtube, reddit, wiki. There are SO MANY ADVERTISEMENTS. You talk about cases I’ve never heard of! It’s great! I just wish you would do less ads, talk less annoying, use real sources. ❤️.Score: 3/5

Love, love, love!I really like this podcast! The only feedback I would give is to slow down a little on some of your stories. You talk really fast on some of the podcasts. I even had to check my phone so see if I was pressing a button lol. Other than that, I love it so I had to give 5 stars. I love your chemistry, I love how devoted you are. You can tell you love what you do & you can just tell how genuine of a person you are. By far my favorite true crimes podcast right now. Also, they’re on YouTube that I just watched too! So happy that I found this podcast! Some of these reviews are ridiculous. Yes, there’s ads. Skip through them then. They get paid for ads, unless you’re actually paying for this, then skip through it. News flash, skipping is free. & some people stated that it sounds like she’s “reading”. Well. Duh. Lol. She’s talking for 30 min to an hour.. is she expected to know all of this information verbatim, weekly?! Also, I love how all these people who are criticizing her grammar also happen to be grammatically incorrect. Lol. These podcasters are doing great ❤️.Score: 5/5

Turpin FamilyI love y’alls podcast! I was wondering if y’all could do an episode on the Turpin family?.Score: 5/5

Love!!!!I found you guys on YouTube and watched all your YouTube videos, then I found your podcast on Apple Podcast and saw you guys had so many more videos on here! You guys are the dream team! Love the way you guys respect the victims and make it more about them. Love u guys!.Score: 5/5

Must listen!They are wonderful. They keep the outside commentary to a minimum and get to the point. They are both appreciative of their listeners and don't come off arrogant or too famous to respond or acknowledge their listeners. If you are looking for a good crime podcast that gets to the point and doesn’t make commentary or insert their opinions- this is it!.Score: 5/5

The best podcast by far !!Love you both help me get through my days at work such great story teller & ur husband has such great reviews just binge your podcast & YouTube channel also ♥️ nothing but love keep it up guys I’ll spread the word 🙌🏽.Score: 5/5

Snap!I found you guys on Snapchat and crossed my fingers and hoped y’all had a podcast! I love your show!!.Score: 5/5

LoveAbsolutely love your show. I have 2 young children and in my rare me time. I’m listening to your show..Score: 5/5

Love,Love,loveThe first podcast I actually fell in love with! Host are super down to earth! Great information, sites sourced, pictures include on social media, and great narration! Cant wait to see both Payton and garter grow as a podcast and couple!! #Detroitlistener #MWMH #MURDERWITHMYHUSBAND #iloveit #ihateit.Score: 5/5

Love itStumbled on to this podcast, love a lot of true crime shows, especially Crime Junkie! I love how different this one is and how a lot of it is unscripted! The couples banter is also fun to listen to!.Score: 5/5

I LOVE THIS PODCASTI am obsessed with this podcast it is so amazing Garrett is so funny and you guys are the cutest couple!! LOVE YOU GUYSSS.Score: 5/5

Garret’s “OH MY GOSH” is the reason for my 5 starsFound out about this pod on tik tok and its fantastic. Paytons voice is very calm and soothing which helps me get through some of the gruesome stories. Garrets “oh my gosh” is great and is very funny..Score: 5/5

Fantastic PodcastI’ve been searching for weeks for a GOOD truecrime podcast and finally found the one! I follow them on TikTok as well and that’s how I knew about their podcast. Stories are always told well and are always interesting!! -Upstate,NY.Score: 5/5

Very scripted, sounds like reading right off a paperThe content of this podcast is amazing, the research is very thorough and the backstories are thoroughly explained. However it is very hard to listen to at times because the female sounds like she is reading directly off a paper and too scripted- this podcast sounds more like an audiobook than an actual podcast which is rough when you prefer more podcast style listening..Score: 3/5

Love this showHave a total crush on both Payton and Garebear.Score: 5/5

Great in dosesLoved it initially. This might sound rude but it gets annoying. Too much referencing the LDS church as well as a lot of topics that are discussed aren’t researched. It gets old when you reference something you don’t know about like when you guys talked about the movie scream yet neither of you have seen it and there’s been a handful of other instances where this is the case. Also when you guys use words in place of swear words but they sound almost exactly the same just say the word, like you’re grown adults a word doesn’t matter especially if it’s the right context to use it..Score: 3/5

Binge worthy!I’m losing sleep because I cant stop listening! Love this couple and this podcast!.Score: 5/5

Yay podcastAbsolutely love this podcast! I started listening while at work and then I got my boyfriend into it and now we listen every time we go on road-trips!.Score: 5/5

“Ads with my Husband”I enjoy listening to the episodes, but the way she mispronounces some things is very cringe. Also, if you are going to have the majority of your episode be ads, at least put them all at the very beginning so we are constantly skipping..Score: 2/5

Great podcastThey always focus so much on the victims and I love the dynamic of Garrett not knowing the story. It makes it such a better podcasts because Payton tells it as a story and she is such a great story teller! They don’t have tons of random side convos either which I really like too.Score: 5/5

🤌🏽Stop spoiling “You”.Score: 1/5

OBSESSEDEdit: i binged every episode in like a week and my only complaint is that I have to wait for new episodes. LOVE PAYTON AND GARRETT!! I love true crime and true crime podcasts. I’ve been trying to find one that I haven’t already binged and I found this on tik tok last week, I’ve listened to like 20 episodes already and I’m addicted. I’ll be sad when I’m caught up!.Score: 5/5

Absolutely adore these guys!<3For this being my first ever podcast that I’ve ever listened to I’ve been so in love with it. I believe I heard a sound on tiktok of one of their stories and decided to look them up. In the past week I’ve listened to almost every episode they have on their account. The perfect mix of a funny/adorable couple and chilling true crime!.Score: 5/5

The husband really doesn’t listen.I really like the show. It’s the first true crime podcast I’ve ever listened to. I stumbled upon it looking at tiktok one day. One minor gripe: the husband really doesn’t listen to any of the details when the wife is setting up the case.He routinely asks questions about things she has JUST mentioned. Keep up the good work! lol.Score: 4/5

Love love love this Podcast!!!It’s actually my first time listening to podcasts & I’m very intrigued! I love Peyton & Garrett, his reactions are always priceless. I literally tell everyone I know to check out your podcasts & so far good feedback from everyone! I don’t know if I’m the only one but I’m very suspicious of everyone now since listening, can never be too safe! Keep going, I love it!.Score: 5/5

Very interesting podcastAs a former investigator of crimes against children ranging from SA, trafficking, homicide, and accidental death. It’s very interesting to see the conclusions this married duo can arrive to. They play very well off of each other and are very entertaining. Thank you for giving a voice to these victims and their families. Time may have forgotten but we never will. Continue the great research!.Score: 5/5

Amazing !I found you on TikTok am I loved your content your podcast is amazing I love it I listen every morning at work 10 out of 10 would recommend..Score: 5/5

Love it!Listening from the beginning and can’t stop! Love seeing the perspective of someone who doesn’t know much about true crime on cases that I’ve heard before and being introduced to new cases. Keep up the great work!.Score: 5/5

❤️❤️I love love love this podcast and so does my mom we listen almost all the time.Score: 5/5

I love itI started listening to you guys not too long ago and I am finally all caught up. I don’t know what I’m going to do now. Anyways, you guys are amazing! I started newer to oldest and I love how you guys have evolved sooo much lol. I am happy y’all dropped the sound effects 😁 I knew I liked crime and investigation (I’m a CSI fan) but this is something awesome that I have discovered I “LOVE IT” a lot. Keep up the amazing work you guys are doing. I love it and my fiancé hates it lol literally..Score: 5/5

Awesome!!!10 out 10 recommended!!!! Me and my husband are on a roll just listing to all of the episodes!.Score: 5/5

Love y’allHello from Texas! My daughter got me turned onto y’all. From the first listen I was hooked. I love listening to you both. This podcast keeps my attention where I loose interest in others. Also I just bought merchandise..Score: 5/5

The best!I’m obsessed! Someone recommended this podcast to me and I am hooked. I literally listened to every single episode in a span of 2 weeks. My bf really enjoys this as well! Y’all are appreciated! ❤️.Score: 5/5

Best of the best!!!I never write reviews but I am a huge fan of true crime and this podcast is BY FAR my favorite one I’ve ever listened to! Payton and Garrett are so enjoyable to listen to and have very fun personalities, they are simply the best😊 keep it coming!!.Score: 5/5

AMAZINGMy boyfriend and I are OBSESSED with this podcast! We have listened/watch SO MANY and literally every single one is explained so well and we absolutely love it!.Score: 5/5

Obsessed!!!This has seriously become not only my favorite true crime podcast, but my favorite overall podcast I have ever listened to! I honestly recommend it to everyone, as anyone can listen to these episodes with a variety on knowledge of true crime. There is the perfect mix of Payton’s story telling and Garrett’s questions that keep things clear, they are the perfect duo! There’s not enough praise to give to this podcast, and it’s so amazing to see two people so dedicated and motivated to provide the best content possible. Absolutely amazing! :).Score: 5/5

Love this podcastI absolutely love this podcast, i discovered them in tiktok and immediately fell in love. i’ve been listening to them non stop! my husband even listens to it with me on long drives which is funny cuz he hates crime stuff lol.Score: 5/5

SuperficialI enjoyed this podcast at first, but lately the episodes have been disappointing. Not very well researched (often just a few TV shows are cited) and superficial..Score: 2/5

The best podcast!I have a hard time getting into podcasts because I lose interest so fast. But not murder with my husband! I look forward to their episodes weekly!.Score: 5/5

LOVE LOVE LOVE!!!Love y’all’s podcast so much! Can I suggest y’all do the Colt Morgan case in Buffalo, Tx..Score: 5/5

The cutest true crime podcast!I’m a huge true crime fan and listen to a lot of podcasts but I love this show so much because it’s true crime with a lighter feel . Garrett and Payton are a great couple who make it so easy to listen to some cases I haven’t heard before with a little humor. Keep it up 💕.Score: 5/5

Performanece Lab 🎯Performance Lab ® CORE Formulas support all aspects of human performance, across all walks of life. Boosts work performance and productivity with nootropics for focus, multitasking under stress, creative problem-solving and more. Buy Now!AdvertorialScore: 5/5

Amazing!I just got on to this podcast and it’s incredible! Absolutely love it. So well done. Highly recommend for anyone who loves true crime..Score: 5/5

Amazing!!!Recently started listening from the very first episodes. Absolutely love this podcast!.Score: 5/5

Love from OzHi guys, I found you from a recommendation on Facebook. Love your podcast, you are very easy to listen to and Garrett is so funny and has some good theories. Keep up the good work. Love from Australia xx Janice.Score: 5/5

Best podcastLove love love !!! You guys are the best.Score: 5/5

All the way from AustraliaAbsolutely loving this, and can’t wait to get in the car, and bedtime listen! THANKYOU!.Score: 5/5

Yes yes yes!!!Just do it, start from the start and JUST DO IT! So worth it 🤩👌.Score: 5/5

Never liked true crime until nowI was never a fan of true crime (like the husband) but with your interaction and story telling, I can’t stop listening. Listening from Sydney, Australia!.Score: 5/5

New listenerI’m a new listener and I am hooked! Every bit of spare time I get I’m listening. My favourite podcast..Score: 5/5

Addictive…Love, love, love everything about this podcast ❤️.Score: 5/5

ObsessedAbsolutely loving this podcast! Garret and Payton are so easy to listen to and do such a great job..Score: 5/5

Love it!I just started listening a few weeks ago and I’ve since binged everything episode. Obsessed!.Score: 5/5

10/10I’m so invested in this podcast, and this one alone. I literally listen to it at night to fall asleep! You guys are killing it! Thank you so much! 10/10 recommend!.Score: 5/5

<3I have only be listening for 2 day and im up to episode 35 (I have been listening backwards tho) So good definitely recommend and I love his 10 seconds.Score: 5/5

ObsessedCaught wind of this episode from a Tiktok a friend sent me about Gaby Petito and I literally haven’t stopped listening all week. Peyton, your ability to take a case and condense it down into such a whirlwind of a story is amazing! And your voice, so calming given you’re talking about serious crimes! Up there with one of my fave podcasts 😄.Score: 5/5

Love this podcast!!!!I have fallen in love with this podcasts and it’s wonderful hosts! I find the content so interesting and you can tell how much work and effort Payton puts into these. She is so well researched and her passion is really clear. This podcast so entertaining and captivating. The hosts are genuine people and are truly humbled. I will be a long time fan!! I highly highly recommend. Everyone I have showed it to has loved it!.Score: 5/5

Love thisListening to this from Brisbane Australia. Great Podcast thank you 😁👍🏻.Score: 5/5

Love!!Loving your podcast! Thanks for keeping it interesting! From Brisbane, Australia 🇦🇺.Score: 5/5

I LOVE IT!I love listening to your podcast. I have started at the start and very quickly making my way through all episodes. Highly recommend for anyone that loves true crime..Score: 5/5

I’m obsessed!!Such an amazing podcast! I can accidentally listen to story after story for hours on end because the stories are so well researched and entertaining, love it.Score: 5/5

What a findOMG I’m so glad I found this podcast. Have nearly caught up in just a week of listening. To say I love it is an understatement. Keep up the great work. All the way from Townsville, Australia..Score: 5/5

ReviewI seriously love this podcast and you guys! But there’s too many adds, especially in the Ying Ying episode. I get you have to make money but it’s a bit much to have so many all the time..Score: 3/5

ObsessedOn my child free days I love listening to your podcast whilst cleaning, doing jobs around home and driving! Loving it all the way from Brisbane ✌🏽.Score: 5/5

Absolutely Amazing!My favourite True Crime podcast! Having Payton know everything and tell Garrett the story as well as listeners was a really creative way to do this! Awesome content :).Score: 5/5

Excellent show but advertisements getting a bit muchMy girlfriend referred me this show and I really enjoy it, the commentary from both sides is great. However, in saying this the last episode had 3 advertisements in 18 minutes which really just takes away the flow of the episode. I often listen to the show while driving and so can’t “skip” the ads. I understand the ads help keep the show running and allow for better development as the channel grows but the increase in ads is really putting me off the podcast altogether. Again I really love the show but in my opinion the ads are really reducing the quality of the show Edit - thank you guys for listening to fan feedback..Score: 5/5

One of my Faves 💜I have no idea how this podcast got recommended to me but THANK YOU. I think this is the best true crime podcast out there. I just love how you go in depth with important details and with most cases under an hour. I can tell Payton does her research. Plus the husband (Garrett) who always asking the questions we wondering as well. Amazing content Love from Fiji . Caroline.Score: 5/5

Listening all the way from Australia 🇦🇺Love listening to you guys! I like that there’s minimal chat outside the case, you always get to the point, you’re clear, and easy to follow! Plus you cover so many good cases. Keep up the good work!.Score: 5/5

Love!You guys are the best! This podcast has taken over my life ☠️.Score: 5/5

So good!Really loving this podcast. Cases are diverse. Well told and Payton and Garrett remind me of my partner and myself! Keep up the great work :).Score: 5/5

MurderThis show is great. It helps me sleep and I have had sleeping problems in the past so this show really helps. Thank you Garret and Payton..Score: 5/5

Love it!!Hey Payton, I’m not even a true crime fan but you make this so entertaining! I love your accent. From Australia..Score: 5/5

12/10One of the best true crime podcasts and YouTube channels I’ve tuned into! Even if I’ve heard the stories before it’s super interesting getting different perspectives! Particularly from someone that’s not into true crime as Garrett is, awesome job guys!.Score: 5/5

Very easy to listen to!Absolutely love this podcast, so easy to listen to. Listening from Nhulunbuy, Northern Territory Australia 💓.Score: 5/5

Best PodcastI am now 8 episodes in and am officially addicted. This is legit the best podcast I’ve ever found..Score: 5/5

Hello from down under 🇦🇺LOVING the podcast guys!! So informative & enjoyable to listen too during lockdown in Australia!.Score: 5/5

A great teamYou have a fan here in Tasmania, Australia. I really enjoy your back and forth, listening to cases I haven’t previously heard of, and also getting more info on cases I have heard of..Score: 5/5

Obsessed!My new fave podcast - love listening to you guys! Love from all the way over in Geelong, Victoria, Australia ❤️.Score: 5/5

Great podcast!Love listening to this podcast and you guys! 💖 I love how respectful you are about the victims and how you tell the cases. From Emma in Melbourne Australia! 😊.Score: 5/5

The best podcastMy absolute favourite podcast! The only one yet that I haven’t skipped through love the content and how it’s run.Score: 5/5

AddictiveObsessed with your podcast! You guys are the best. Sammy, from Gold Coast Australia 🤙🏽.Score: 5/5

Love your podcastMy partner and I listen to them on our drive to and from work and make the trip go so quickly, I loveee them so much 🤍.Score: 5/5

Highly recommendG’day long time listener first time reviewer. Ok so I’m not one to write reviews but I’ve got to say…..this is a fair dinkum podcast to listen to. I’ve just spent the last 3 days driving through parts of Australia that has no cell reception and I usually listen to Spotify, but I’ve watched most of your YouTube videos and thought I’d give the early episodes a crack. I’m 100% more of a visual learner and prefer to see what’s happening but the two of you made a super easy podcast to listen too…. Kept me engaged and focused whilst driving through the beautiful Australian scenery…. .keep up the good work.Score: 5/5

BEST PODCASTMy favourite podcast I have ever come across, found these 2 on tiktok and now in 1 day have listened to 4 of these!!.Score: 5/5

AmazingFound you on TikTok and have nearly finished all your episodes addicted!!!.Score: 5/5

WowI have never been a huge fan of this stuff but I love how factual you guys are plus you always look at what it could have been. From Australian, saw it on tictok, it’s awesome to see what you look like too.Score: 5/5

Best crime podcast ever!BEST CRIME PODCAST EVER! I’m so glad I found you guys. You’re so good at telling stories and I love that your husband is there saying what we are all thinking. Since I found your podcast I can’t listen to any others because they are so boring compared to you! Keep it up! Love you guys and the podcast so so much! Thank you for your hard work and for continuing this podcast! Love from Australia! ☺️.Score: 5/5

Hello and thank you from Melbourne, Australia!My new favourite podcast!.Score: 5/5

Murder Mum & DadI come across you guys on a TikTok and thought…….. I need this in my life!!! It’s been 5 days now and I’m up to episode 35, I’m bingeing until I’m caught up!!! Love you both Kylie from Australia.Score: 5/5

BingedSo easy to listen to. Very enjoyable. Thanks for the great podcast. Would love longer episodes. Katie. Australia.Score: 5/5

Love itActually just started to listening to this because I had caught up on all my other podcast but this! Omg this is now my #1 favourite podcast !! Love love love it, I listen to it al day every day at work !!.Score: 5/5

ObsessedThis is easily by far my favourite podcast. The stories have great variety, with enough episodes about survival to not be too dark, the reactions from Garrett “the husband” are authentic and the length of each episode is perfect, 30-40 mins generally! I get through an episode a day to and from work and now that I am running out of episodes I will join patreon because I can’t get enough! Amazing amazing! Thank you and much love from Australia 🇦🇺❤️.Score: 5/5

Coursera 💡Start your future on coursera today! Build skills with courses, certificates, and degrees online from world-class universities and companies. Join for Free!AdvertorialScore: 5/5

Victoriag13_MeylinRM Murder with my husband.Score: 5/5

Hxllyann6Murder With My Husband is the best podcast about.Score: 5/5

White777andrew clairlemon: I’ve become obsessed with this Danish TV show “The Killing” (it can be streamed on SBS on demand). It takes a whole series….Score: 5/5

CormorantHobo clairlemon: I’ve become obsessed with this Danish TV show “The Killing” (it can be streamed on SBS on demand). It takes a whole series….Score: 5/5

ClairlemonI’ve become obsessed with this Danish TV show “The Killing” (it can be streamed on SBS on demand). It takes a whole… .Score: 5/5

LinnieVII“I’m feeling pretty rested if you want to try cracking the secret code in our murder mystery box,” my husband just… .Score: 5/5

MadelaineLucieHWhy did I murder my husband in the pantry with the candlestick, Mr Holmes? *laughs cruelly* a LaCk oF poSitIvE Ro… .Score: 5/5

GonoFriezaMeNtAl_MiChAeL That’s quite the day! My husband is playing golf with my father, my son is gaming with his online f… .Score: 5/5

Shilla008 FoxyGinnah: No your honor. I did not murder my husband with the wolf’s bane I’ve been growing in the backyard for 18 months to inherit….Score: 5/5

Topgirls CathRobilliard: K_IngalaSmith My husband’s cousin is crowdfunding for a colleague and his wife stabbed to death in their own home last….Score: 5/5

AirBNB 🎁Get $64 off on your first stay at travels. Claim your $64 Airbnb free credit by clicking here!AdvertorialScore: 5/5

Murder With My Husband Podcast Episodes

87. Micaela Costanzo - The Wendover Slaying

On this episode of MWMH, Payton and Garrett discuss the abduction and murder of 16-year-old Mickie. Case Sources: Dateline episode Links: Ads: HydroJug: and use code: HUSBAND Raycon: - 15% off Best Fiends HelloFresh: and use code husband14 for up to 14 free meals, plus free shipping! Sarah Flint: Magic Spoon: use code HUSBAND SundanceNow: use code HUSBAND Olive and June: use code HUSBAND Learn more about your ad-choices at

86. The Gitchie Manitou Murders

MERCH LIVE NOW: On this episode of MWMH, Payton and Garrett discuss the slaughter of the Gitchie Manatou Five by evil brothers. Case Sources: Killer Siblings Season 2 Episode 2 Links: Ads: Curateur: use code HUSBAND Ritual: That’s 10% off at Apostrophe: use code HUSBAND My fitness pal: code HUSBAND Betterhelp: Learn more about your ad-choices at

85. YingYing Zhang - The Dedicated Student

On this episode of MWMH, Payton and Garrett discuss the abduction and murder of college student, YingYing Zhang in 2017. Case Sources: JCS - The Case of Brendt Christensen ABC 20/20 Undercover Girlfriend - donate here - undercover audio Links: Ads: Seed: and use code HUSBAND Bombas: HydroJug: and use code: HUSBAND Simpli Safe: Raycon: - 15% off Daily Harvest: Quip: Learn more about your ad-choices at

84. Alison Botha - The Inspiring Story

On this episode of MWMH, Payton and Garrett discuss the abduction and attempted murder of 27-year-old Alison Botha in South Africa, 1994. Case Sources: Alison Documentary on Amazon Prime Links: Petition - Ads: HelloFresh: and use code husband14 for up to 14 free meals, plus free shipping! Ritual: That’s 10% off at Betterhelp: Best Fiends LightStream: Amazon Music: Learn more about your ad-choices at

83. Martha Moxley - Infamous Halloween Case

On this episode of MWMH, Payton and Garrett discuss the infamous murder of 15-year-old Martha Moxley on Halloween night, 1975. Infamous due to the possible ties to a presidential family and the case remaining unsolved for all these years. Case Sources: Murder and Justice: The Case of Martha Moxley which is hosted by former prosecutor Laura Coates. Links: Ads: Curateur: use code HUSBAND Warby Parker: My fitness pal: code HUSBAND Sarah Flint: and use code husband14 for up to 14 free meals, plus free shipping! Learn more about your ad-choices at

82. Shauna Howe and Shenee Freeman - The Halloween Abductions

*case involves children* Case Sources: Cold Case Files Episode 1 - Little Girl Lost Lake Erie Murders Season 2 Episode 1 Links: Ads: SundanceNow: use code HUSBAND Apostrophe: use code HUSBAND Olive and June: use code HUSBAND Betterhelp: HydroJug: and use code: HUSBAND Learn more about your ad-choices at

Spooky Stories - Week 2

On this bonus episode of MWMH, Payton and Garrett read Spooky Stories written in by listeners! Learn more about your ad-choices at

81. B.J. Liske - The Liske Family Murders

On this episode of MWMH, Payton and Garrett discuss the Liske Family Murders. Case Sources: killings/ crime-114279f06b8c Links: ADS: code HUSBAND Learn more about your ad-choices at

Spooky Stories - Week 1

On this bonus episode of MWMH, Payton and Garrett read Spooky Stories written in by listeners! Learn more about your ad-choices at

Easy Hits

Murder With My Husband Similar Podcasts

True podcast
TrueRyan Cabrera17 August 2004Pop13 EpisodesFREE
Dr. Death | S2: Dr. Fata podcast
Dr. Death | S2: Dr. FataWondery08 November 2021True Crime10 EpisodesFREE
The Generation Why Podcast podcast
The Generation Why PodcastWondery22 November 2021True Crime359 EpisodesFREE
Culpable podcast
CulpableTenderfoot TV, Black Mountain Media & Cadence 1308 September 2021True Crime23 EpisodesFREE
True Crime Obsessed podcast
True Crime ObsessedObsessed Network18 November 2021True Crime272 EpisodesFREE
Mystery and Murder: Analysis by Dr. Phil podcast
Mystery and Murder: Analysis by Dr. PhilStage 29 Podcast Productions22 November 2021True Crime61 EpisodesFREE
Hide Your Identity!
Brain Force
Free Website Traffic
Faster Hosting
You were invited to try Coinbase!Coinbase is the world's most trusted place to buy and sell cryptocurrency. Open an account today, and if you buy or sell $100 or more of crypto, you'll receive $10 worth of free Bitcoin!